Contradictions in the Bible: How to Understand Difficult Scriptures

If you have spent enough time reading the Bible, you have probably come across a passage that made you wonder, “Wait… didn’t another part of the Bible say something different?”

Maybe someone has pointed out supposed contradictions online. Maybe you noticed that two Gospel writers describe the same event differently. Or maybe you have read two verses sitting right next to each other that seem to disagree.

These are fair questions.

Christians do not need to be afraid of examining difficult passages. If Scripture is worth trusting, it is also worth reading carefully. Many apparent contradictions become clearer when we understand context, genre, perspective, and the way ancient authors communicated.

So, does the Bible contradict itself?

The answer requires us to look a little closer.

First, What Is a Contradiction?

A true contradiction happens when two statements cannot both be true in the same sense and at the same time.

For example, saying “Jesus was born in Bethlehem” and “Jesus was not born in Bethlehem” would be a direct contradiction.

But two accounts including different details are not automatically contradictory. Neither are two teachings meant for different situations.

That distinction matters because some biblical passages sound inconsistent at first glance while actually addressing different circumstances or emphasizing different parts of the same event.

Sometimes the Bible Uses Tension to Teach Wisdom

One of the clearest examples appears in Proverbs 26.

Proverbs 26:4 - “Do not answer a fool according to his folly, or you yourself will be just like him.”

Then the very next verse says:

Proverbs 26:5 - “Answer a fool according to his folly, or he will be wise in his own eyes.”

So which is it?

Should we answer a foolish person or not?

Both verses are intentionally placed together because wisdom requires discernment. Sometimes responding to foolishness only pulls us into it. At other times, foolishness needs to be challenged.

Proverbs are not simple formulas that apply exactly the same way in every situation. They teach us how to think wisely.

We use similar sayings today. We might say, “Look before you leap,” but also, “He who hesitates is lost.” Those statements are not necessarily contradictory. Wisdom means knowing which principle applies to the situation in front of you.

Sometimes biblical tension is not a problem to solve. It is an invitation to discern.

Context Changes Everything

Many supposed contradictions disappear when we read the surrounding passage.

Consider these two statements:

Galatians 6:2 - “Carry each other’s burdens.”

Then a few verses later:

Galatians 6:5 - “For each one should carry their own load.”

Should we carry one another’s burdens, or should everyone carry their own?

Both.

Christians should help one another through overwhelming burdens, while each person must also take responsibility for their own life.

Context shows that the verses are addressing different realities.

That is why we should ask more than, “What does this verse say?” We should also ask, “Who is speaking? Who are they speaking to? What is happening in the passage? What kind of writing am I reading?”

The Bible Contains Different Kinds of Writing

The Bible includes history, poetry, wisdom literature, prophecy, letters, parables, songs, and apocalyptic imagery.

We naturally interpret different kinds of writing differently.

When Psalm 91 says God will cover us “with his feathers,” we understand that as poetic imagery. When Proverbs describes what usually happens when people live wisely, we should not automatically treat every statement as an unconditional promise. When Revelation uses beasts, horns, and dragons, we recognize that we are reading symbolic language.

Reading the Bible faithfully means allowing poetry to be poetry, wisdom to be wisdom, history to be history, and symbolism to function as symbolism.

Problems can arise when we force every biblical passage to communicate in exactly the same way.

What About Differences Between the Gospels?

Some of the most common questions about biblical contradictions involve Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

The Gospel writers sometimes include different details, arrange events differently, summarize conversations differently, or focus on different people.

Consider the resurrection accounts.

Matthew mentions Mary Magdalene and “the other Mary.”

Mark names Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, and Salome.

Luke mentions Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and others.

John begins by focusing specifically on Mary Magdalene.

At first glance, someone might ask, “So how many women went?”

But one writer mentioning two people while another mentions three does not automatically mean one of them is wrong. A writer may simply choose which details to emphasize.

We do this in everyday conversation. If you said, “I went to dinner with Chris,” and later someone learned that James and Sarah were there too, your first statement would not suddenly become false. You simply did not name everyone.

John’s account even has Mary later say, “We don’t know where they have put him,” suggesting that others were involved even though John initially focuses on her.

Different Perspectives Do Not Mean Different Truths

The four Gospels are not four photocopies of one another.

Each writer emphasizes different aspects of Jesus’ life and ministry. Matthew often highlights how Jesus fulfills Scripture. Mark moves quickly and emphasizes Jesus’ actions. Luke frequently draws attention to outsiders and the marginalized. John focuses heavily on Jesus’ identity and signs.

Their differences can actually help us see more.

Think about four people describing the same wedding. The bride’s mother, the best man, a photographer, and a close friend may all remember different details. Their accounts can be different without being mutually exclusive.

In the same way, the Gospel writers can tell the same larger story from different perspectives.

Some Passages Are Harder Than Others

That does not mean every apparent discrepancy has an easy explanation.

Jesus’ genealogies in Matthew and Luke contain significant differences. Some events appear in different orders. Numbers in parallel Old Testament accounts can differ. There are also places where ancient manuscripts contain textual variations.

Christians and biblical scholars have offered explanations for many of these passages, but some questions remain debated.

We do not strengthen faith by pretending every difficult passage is simple.

It is okay to say, “I don’t know exactly how these passages fit together.”

Faith does not require pretending we have solved every question. It invites us to keep studying, learning, and growing in humility.

Differences Can Help Us Read More Carefully

Interestingly, apparent contradictions can actually make us better Bible readers.

Why does Matthew tell the story this way?

Why does Luke include this detail?

Why does John leave something out?

Why are two Proverbs giving seemingly opposite advice?

Those questions can move us beyond simply collecting isolated Bible verses and into actually studying Scripture.

The Bible is remarkably unified, but unity does not mean uniformity. It contains many authors, voices, genres, and perspectives woven together into one larger story about God and His work in the world.

How Should You Approach an Apparent Contradiction?

When you find a passage that seems to conflict with another, slow down.

Read both passages in context. Pay attention to genre. Ask whether the statements truly cancel each other out or simply emphasize different details. Consider whether the writers are speaking to different audiences or situations.

Compare translations. Consult trustworthy commentaries. Learn something about the historical and cultural setting.

And be willing to sit with some unanswered questions.

You do not have to choose between blind acceptance and automatic skepticism.

There is another option: careful, humble investigation.

Our Faith Is Not Afraid of Questions

Jesus told people who studied Scripture carefully:

John 5:39–40 - “You study the Scriptures diligently… These are the very Scriptures that testify about me.”

The goal of studying difficult passages is not simply to win arguments about the Bible. It is to know the God revealed through it.

Some apparent contradictions disappear when we understand context. Others reveal intentional tensions designed to teach wisdom. Some reflect different perspectives or literary techniques. And a few may leave us with questions we continue to wrestle with.

But questions do not have to destroy faith.

Sometimes they are exactly what pushes us toward a deeper one.

A Prayer for Understanding

God, thank You for giving us Your Word. Give us wisdom when Scripture is difficult to understand and humility when we encounter questions we cannot immediately answer. Help us read carefully, seek truth honestly, and resist both shallow answers and quick skepticism. Most of all, help us know You more deeply through the story Scripture tells.

Amen.

-----

Join us this Sunday at The Path Church in Atlanta and grow with a community committed to staying faithful and on mission. Get connected today!